Click to show filters
OK
Click to show filters
OK
Site-wide
Recipes
Articles
Search within
Browse all

Ask the experts: Diet Coke vs Coke Zero

Q:  "I'd like to know if Coke Zero or Diet Coke is better to drink. I realise that Coke in general is not the healthiest choice, but I'd like to know if I do choose to drink Coke, which one is best?

Sophie

A: We asked nutritionist Amanda Johnson to respond.

"Coke Zero and Diet Coke are actually very similar. Both are low calorie drinks and have exactly the same ingredients – carbonated purified water, colour (caramel 150d), food acids (338 and 331), flavour, artificial sweeteners aspartame (951) and acesulphame potassium (950), preservative (211) and caffeine. The key difference between the two drinks is in the proportions of these ingredients, giving each has a slightly different flavour profile.

There is a little difference in nutrient content: both provide less than 4kJ energy (nothing) and have less than 40mg sodium per 250ml (1 cup). So, between these two choices, it's really a matter of which one you prefer! If you are watching your sugar and energy intake, either of these will be better than the standard Coca Cola, which contains 450kJ and 26g of sugar in 250ml.

In general terms though, when thinking about what to drink, it's recommended that we have plenty of water, and that we have an overall fluid intake equivalent to 6-8 glasses daily. Low fat milk is a good choice as an alternative to water or soft drinks. High-sugar drinks such as fruit juice, cordial, energy drinks and soft drinks should be limited, and if you're susceptible to the effects of caffeine, it's a good idea to minimise consumption of coffee, tea and other caffeinated drinks such as Coca Cola."

3 Comments. Add yours

yiellll says:

"have exactly the same ingredients " NO. Just because two different products have "Natural flavors" added, doesn't make them the same "Natural Flavors" which have been added.

They are not the same. Anyone who thinks so hasn't tasted them.

Yiellll - are you nutritionist? Is that a field that you are an expert in? The nutritionist (Amanda Johnson), who was asked to comment on this subject, clearly stated that the difference is the proportion of those same ingredients which results in different flavours. Wouldn't you agree that using the exact same ingredients but in different proportions can change the flavour of something? Maybe next time you make a meal that uses garlic, try adding 5 times as much as you normally would and see if that makes a difference to the flavour. Perhaps you shouldn't be so rude in future and try reading articles more carefully before jumping down someone's throat!

Amanda Johnson, yiellll and ks68
If you happen to check the coca-cola website you will see that infact the ingredients to both diet coke and coke zero are DIFFERENT to coke original in that the original contains SUGAR in the form of high fructose corn syrup or sucrose derived from cane sugar [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coca-Cola_formula]

[http://www.coca-cola.co.uk/brands/coca-cola.html]
[http://www.coca-cola.co.uk/brands/diet-coke.html]
[http://www.coca-cola.co.uk/brands/coke-zero.html]